About the Inn

Small table for two with two high chairs and a tray with tea and flowers

Welcome to West Neck Guesthouse, offering quaint Shelter Island lodging. The property offers comfortable and beautifully appointed guest rooms all with king beds, private baths, flat screen TV’s with cable, and Wi-Fi. If you are looking for a peaceful and relaxing getaway on Shelter Island, you have found your spot.

Our overnight guests can start the day with an in room coffee or tea and a voucher for a light breakfast at a nearby local bakery.

Outside Spaces
The backyard at West Neck Guesthouse is available for guest use and is the perfect place to relax after a day out exploring Shelter Island. Sip a glass of local Long Island wine while relaxing in one of the inviting seating areas or head to the beach which is a very short walk from West Neck Guesthouse to view an amazing sunset at Crescent Beach.

Pool & Lounge at Shelter Island House
Our Flagship Property, Shelter Island House, is located just a 2 minute drive or a short walk from this property. Enjoy a swim in the  pool surrounded by gardens or simply lounge poolside for the afternoon. Hungry or Thirsty? Stop into the Hotel restaurant 18 Bay for a refreshing cocktail and a snack from the Enoteca on your way back from the beach.

We are excited to share the amenities of Shelter Island House with our West Neck Guesthouse visitors!