About the Inn

Small table for two with two high chairs and a tray with tea and flowers

Welcome to West Neck Guesthouse, offering quaint Shelter Island lodging. The property offers comfortable and beautifully appointed guest rooms all with king beds, private baths, flat screen TV’s with cable, and Wi-Fi. If you are looking for a peaceful and relaxing getaway on Shelter Island, you have found your spot.


Enjoy a complimentary eye-opener breakfast at our sister property Shelter Island House between 8 am – 10 am. Shelter Island House is located just up the block at 11 Stearns Point Rd. Please call 631-749-1633 to book.

Outside Spaces

The backyard at West Neck Guesthouse is available for guest use and the perfect place to relax after a day out exploring Shelter Island. Sip a glass of local Long Island wine while relaxing in one of the many seating areas or grab some beach chairs and watch the sunset at Crescent Beach, a short walk from West Neck.

Shelter Island House

Our sister Property, Shelter Island House, is located just a 2 minute drive or a short walk from the property. Join us for coffee, tea and pastries offered daily from 8 am-10 am in the lounge or pop in for a refreshing cocktail on your way back from the beach!

Pool & Lounge at Shelter Island House:

We are excited to share the amenities of Shelter Island House with our West Neck Guesthouse visitors! Enjoy a refreshing dip in our beautiful pool or cozy up at the indoor or outdoor lounge with a good book and a glass of local rosé.

Pet Friendly

Only certain rooms can accommodate pets, must call 631-599-3430 to book. A $150 non-refundable pet fee is required for any stay.