About the Inn

Welcome to West Neck Guesthouse, the newest Shelter Island lodging. The property offers comfy and beautifully appointed guest rooms all with king beds, private baths, flat screen TV’s with cable, and Wi-Fi. If you are looking for a peaceful and relaxing alternative on Shelter Island, you have found your spot.

In-Room Coffee & Tea

Each room includes an In-Room single serve Coffee/Tea Machines, Water, Creamer, Milk & Sugar available in the in-room fridge.


Enjoy complimentary coffee, tea and pastries every morning.

Outside Spaces

The backyard at West Neck Guesthouse is available for guest use and the perfect place to relax after a day out exploring Shelter Island. Sip a glass of local Long Island wine while relaxing in one of the many sitting areas or play a game of Petanque or human sized chess. Jump on one of our complimentary bicycles for a day of island exploration, or grab some beach umbrellas, chairs and towels and hit one of our many beautiful Shelter Island beaches. Crescent Beach is only a short 10 minute walk from West Neck Guest House.


Shelter Island House

Our sister property, Shelter Island House, is located a 2 minute drive or short walk from the property. Join us for a complimentary continental breakfast buffet offered daily, and don’t miss out on fantastic dinners at the on-site Tavern at Shelter Island House! Stop by to pick up complimentary bicycles, beach chairs, towels, and umbrellas to use on nearby Crescent Beach or one of the other gorgeous beaches on Shelter Island.

Pet Friendly

Room 3 and 4 at our Shelter Island Inn allow pets with a $150 non-refundable pet fee for any stay.